By Aditya Kalra, Arpan Chaturvedi and Ricardo Brito, Reuters
Twenty-six extinct Spix's macaws have somehow found their way to the Indian Vantara zoo. Photo: NELSON ALMEIDA/AFP
- Vantara has imported animals from many nations, but denies commercial payments
- EU states scrutinising wildlife-export requests involving India, Vantara
- Brazil has raised concerns about transfer of Spix's macaws to India
- Indian investigation cleared Vantara of any wrongdoing
This is a story about a bird and a family - but this is no ordinary bird and this is no ordinary family.
Spix's macaw, a vivid-blue parrot with elaborate mating rituals, was declared extinct in the wild in 2019. A captive-breeding programme has since seen some of the birds re-introduced to their native habitat in Brazil.
For more than two years, officials on three continents have agitated over why 26 of the creatures ended up at a private zoo in India, run by the philanthropic arm of a conglomerate controlled by Asia's richest family, the Ambanis.
Indian investigators cleared the sanctuary of any wrongdoing this week, but European officials say they are keeping a close watch on any exports to Vantara, while Brazil, Germany and India work towards a possible resolution at a United Nations-administered body that monitors wildlife trade.
The 1416-hectare Vantara animal rescue and rehabilitation centre in Gujarat state says it homes some 2000 species. The venue featured in pre-wedding celebrations last year for the centre's leader, Anant Ambani, the youngest son of billionaire Mukesh Ambani, whose guests included Ivanka Trump and Mark Zuckerberg.
Adjacent to an oil refinery operated by the Ambanis' Reliance Industries, the zoo was inaugurated in March by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
A Reuters analysis of 2500 commercially available customs records shows that, since 2022, the wildlife centre has imported an extraordinary range of exotic species from countries including South Africa, Venezuela, Democratic Republic of Congo and the United Arab Emirates.
The haul resembles a modern-day Noah's Ark - 2896 snakes, 1431 tortoises, 219 tigers, 149 cheetahs, 105 giraffes, 62 chimpanzees, 20 rhinoceroses and scores of reptiles, including spiny-tailed lizards and veiled chameleons.
The shipments were recorded with a declared value of US$9 million (NZ$15.3m), which a Vantara spokesperson said reflected freight and insurance charges, not payments for wildlife.
"They are not commercial transactions in animals," the spokesperson said. "There has never been any commercial consideration paid for any animal transferred to Vantara."
In August, India's Supreme Court ordered investigators to examine whether Vantara's acquisitions and treatment of animals complied with Indian laws and the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES). This week, the court said investigators found no illegality.
This parrot isn't dead, it's in India
The biggest bone of contention has revolved around the Spix's macaws that the park sourced in 2023 from the Association for the Conservation of Threatened Parrots (ACTP), a Germany-based non-profit that partnered with Brazilian authorities to breed the birds, according to customs records, Brazilian officials and CITES documents.
The macaws' journey was detailed in a customs bill of entry seen by Reuters. It showed the birds were flown to Ahmedabad from Berlin on 4 February, 2023, with costs, insurance and freight amounting to US$969 (NZ$1652) per macaw, for a total of $25,194 (NZ$43,000). Customs taxes and local duties of US$19,000 (NZ$32,400) were waived in line with Indian practice.
Brazil says it didn't consent to the parrots' passage to India and has raised its concerns at CITES meetings.
"The Vantara zoo has not yet joined the Spix's Macaw Population Management Program, which is a fundamental condition for the official involvement of this institution in the species conservation effort," the Chico Mendes Institute for Biodiversity Conservation, a Brazilian government agency, told Reuters.
"At the moment, no Indian institutions are participating in the programme, so there is no reason for Spix's macaws to be sent to India."
Brazil ended its agreement with ACTP last year, saying the group had sent Spix's macaws to other countries in "commercial transactions", without Brazilian consent. The nonprofit previously denied that the parrots' transfer was commercial in nature - it didn't respond to a request for comment.
The Vantara spokesperson told Reuters the macaws' transfer was "entirely lawful, non-commercial and undertaken as a conservation-breeding arrangement with ACTP."
India's Central Zoo Authority didn't respond to queries.
Germany's federal environment ministry told Reuters it had cleared the 2023 transfer of macaws to Vantara in "good faith", but didn't consult Brazil at the time.
Last year, after consulting with Brazilian authorities, Germany rejected an application for a further transfer of Spix's macaws to Vantara on the grounds that the zoo was "not a participant" in the species' population management programme, a ministry spokesperson said.
"This decision is currently subject to legal proceedings," the spokesperson added, declining to elaborate.
Popcorn for elephants
In the year ended March 2024, only 20 percent of the 6355 animals that reached Vantara came from India, the centre's annual report showed. Overall, it imported species from 40 countries.
Vantara developed from barren land in 2020 to an area of manicured lawns and jungle-like greenery, satellite imagery provided by Maxar Technologies showed.
In media tours, Anant Ambani showcased kitchens stocked with premium products used to prepare fresh juices, sweets and even popcorn as treats for elephants.
When Modi visited Vantara this year, his office released an eight-minute video of him feeding lion cubs, elephants, rhinos and giraffes. One picture showed a Spix's macaw perched on a prime ministerial hand.
In February, India's government defended Vantara at CITES meetings in Geneva, saying the facility is a "recognised centre for conservation breeding", according to a summary published by CITES.
CITES documents published before its next meeting in November show progress in resolving the inquisition. The CITES secretariat told Reuters there had been consultations involving Brazil, India and Germany, and that Brazilian officials would provide an update.
Still, European officials recently indicated they are keeping an eagle eye on any applications to ship wildlife to Vantara.
In a 1 August response to a lawmaker's concerns about wildlife trade, European environment commissioner Jessika Roswall said EU states "will pay particular attention to any export requests directed towards India and the facility in question", and assess them with "increased scrutiny".
New Delhi judges this week released a summary of the Indian investigators' report.
Among the findings - the export-import permits for Spix's macaws were in order and Vantara was now holding direct talks with Brazil about "rewilding".
"Their deliberations are at a preliminary stage," it said.
- Reuters
